Lump Sum vs Monthly Spousal Support

The idea of a lump sum buyout is appealing. One payment, clean break, no ongoing financial ties to your ex. No worrying about whether the cheque will come each month. No future court battles over variations.

But is it actually a good deal? That depends on the math—and the math is more complicated than most people realize.

Here's how to think about lump sum vs. monthly support, and when each option makes sense.

The Tax Difference: This Changes Everything

This is the single most important thing to understand about lump sum vs. monthly support.

Monthly Payments

• Recipient: Payments are taxable income. You receive $2,000/month but keep less after tax.
• Payor: Payments are tax-deductible. You pay $2,000/month but it costs less after the tax deduction.

Lump Sum

• Recipient: Payment is NOT taxable. You receive $200,000 and keep $200,000.
• Payor: Payment is NOT tax-deductible. You pay $200,000 and it costs $200,000.

Calculating What a Lump Sum Should Be

If monthly payments are worth X, what lump sum equals X? This requires two adjustments:

1. Present Value Calculation

Money today is worth more than money in the future. If you offered someone $100 today or $100 in five years, they'd take the $100 today—they could invest it and have more than $100 by year five.

So $2,000/month for 10 years ($240,000 total) isn't worth $240,000 today. It's worth less. How much less depends on the "discount rate"—typically 3-5% for spousal support calculations.

2. Tax Adjustment

Because lump sum isn't taxable but monthly payments are, you need to compare after-tax values.

For the recipient: A $200,000 lump sum that you keep entirely may be equivalent to $280,000 in monthly payments that get taxed at 30%.

For the payor: A $200,000 lump sum that isn't deductible costs more in real terms than $200,000 in deductible monthly payments.

When Lump Sum Makes Sense

For the Recipient

You want certainty and security: Once you have the money, it's yours. No worrying about whether your ex will keep paying, lose their job, or file for bankruptcy.

You need capital now: If you need money for a down payment on a house, to start a business, to pay off debt, or for some other immediate need, monthly payments don't help. A lump sum gives you access to capital.

Your ex is unreliable: If you have any doubt about whether your ex will actually pay month after month for years, a lump sum eliminates that risk. Enforcement is expensive and stressful.

Your ex has health issues: If the payor is older or in poor health, there's risk they might die or become unable to pay before you've received the full amount. (Support generally ends at death unless the agreement says otherwise.)

You want a clean break: Monthly payments mean ongoing financial ties—contact about payments, knowing each other's addresses, potential conflicts. A lump sum lets you move on completely.

For the Payor

You want certainty: Once you pay, you're done. No risk of future variations increasing your payments. No ongoing obligation hanging over you.

You have the assets: If you have liquid assets or can access them (home equity, investments), a lump sum may be feasible. If all your wealth is tied up in illiquid assets, monthly payments may be your only option.

You want to move on: Monthly payments mean ongoing ties. If you want a complete break, paying a lump sum achieves that.

Your income is unstable: If you're self-employed or in a volatile industry, your income might drop significantly. With monthly payments, you'd still owe the same amount (until you get a variation). With a lump sum, your future income changes don't matter.

When Monthly Payments Make Sense

For the Recipient

You need regular income: If you rely on support payments to cover rent, utilities, and groceries, a lump sum might get spent too quickly. Monthly payments provide discipline and predictable cash flow.

You expect circumstances to improve for you: If support is time-limited and you expect to become self-sufficient, monthly payments are fine. You'll receive what you need during the transition and won't have to manage a large sum.

Your ex is reliable and stable: If there's no concern about enforcement and your ex has stable income, the risks of monthly payments are low.

The tax math favors it: If the payor's tax savings from deducting support are significant, they may be willing to pay a higher total amount monthly than they would as a lump sum. You might get more value overall.

For the Payor

You don't have liquid assets: If you'd have to sell your house, cash out retirement accounts, or go into debt to fund a lump sum, monthly payments may be more practical.

The tax deduction matters: If you're in a high tax bracket, the deduction for monthly payments significantly reduces your actual cost. A $24,000/year payment might only cost you $14,000 after the tax deduction.

You expect the recipient's circumstances to improve: If the recipient is likely to become self-sufficient, remarry, or cohabit, you may be able to reduce or terminate monthly payments through a variation. A lump sum is gone regardless of what happens.

Your income is stable and reliable: If you have steady employment and no concerns about your ability to pay, the risks of monthly payments are manageable.

The Hybrid Approach

You don't have to choose all-or-nothing. Many settlements combine a lump sum with reduced monthly payments.

Hybrid approaches work well when:

• The recipient needs some capital now but also needs ongoing income
• The payor has some liquid assets but not enough for a full buyout
• Both parties want to balance certainty with tax efficiency

Risks to Consider

Risks of Taking a Lump Sum (Recipient)

Running out of money: If you receive $200,000 and spend it, there's no more coming. With monthly payments, you'd continue to receive support even if you made poor financial decisions.

Undervaluing the settlement: If you accept a lump sum that's less than the true present value of monthly payments, you've given up money. Make sure the math is done properly.

No variation if circumstances worsen: If your situation gets worse (health problems, job loss), you can't go back for more. Monthly payments could potentially be increased in extreme circumstances.

Investment risk: You receive the money, but then you need to invest it or manage it. Poor investment decisions or market downturns could erode its value.

Risks of Paying a Lump Sum (Payor)

Overpaying if circumstances would have changed: If the recipient would have become self-sufficient, remarried, or otherwise had support reduced/terminated, you've paid for years of support you might not have owed.

Losing liquidity: A large lump sum payment may deplete your savings, force you to sell assets, or take on debt. This could affect your financial security.

No tax benefit: You lose the ongoing tax deduction you'd get with monthly payments. Over 10 years, that could be tens of thousands of dollars in lost tax savings.

Getting the Lump Sum Value Right

If you're negotiating a lump sum, here's what should go into the calculation:

Step 1: Determine the Monthly Amount

What would monthly support be under the SSAG? Get the range (low, mid, high) and agree on a figure.

Step 2: Determine Duration

How long would support last? Time-limited or indefinite? If indefinite, you need to make assumptions about when it might realistically end.

Step 3: Calculate Present Value

Using an appropriate discount rate (typically 3-5%), calculate what that stream of payments is worth today.

Step 4: Adjust for Taxes

Account for the fact that lump sum is tax-free while monthly payments are taxable. This adjustment depends on the recipient's marginal tax rate.

Step 5: Consider Risk Factors

Is there risk the payor won't pay? Is the recipient's health a factor? These considerations might adjust the value up or down.

Legal Considerations

Courts Generally Prefer Monthly Payments

Courts tend to favor monthly payments because they can be adjusted if circumstances change. If you're negotiating an agreement (rather than having a court decide), you have more flexibility to agree on a lump sum.

Lump Sum Is Final

Once you agree to a lump sum in a separation agreement, that's typically it. The payor can't come back and say "my income dropped, I want some of that back." The recipient can't come back and say "I need more." Make sure you're comfortable with finality before agreeing.

Child Support Is Different

You generally cannot buy out child support with a lump sum. Child support is the child's right, it can be varied as circumstances change, and it typically must be paid periodically. Don't confuse spousal support buyouts with child support.

Try the Calculator

Start by understanding what monthly support might look like in your situation. Then you can work with a financial professional to calculate an equivalent lump sum value.

Remember: the calculator gives you the monthly amount and duration. Converting that to a fair lump sum requires additional calculations for present value and tax adjustments.

---

---

Related Articles

• How Long Does Spousal Support Last? — Duration rules explained
• Tax Rules for Spousal Support — CRA implications
• Why Is My SSAG Range So Wide? — Understanding amount calculations
• Property Division vs Spousal Support — Trading between the two

---